AUSTIN, Texas — The top two seeds in the NCAA Division II Volleyball South Central Regional both lost heartbreaking five-set matches in their respective conference tournament semifinals. Colorado School of Mines fell to Colorado Mesa in the Rocky Mountain Athletic Conference Tournament, while St. Edward's upset Angelo State on the Rambelles' home court.
Now, the seventh-seeded Hilltoppers (19-11) return to the scene of the crime in San Angelo, looking to engineer another upset as they face second-seed Colorado School of Mines (24-4) on Thursday at 1:30 p.m.
Mines returns several core members from last season's regional semifinal team, including Jenna McLaughlin and Cadence McDonald, who combined for 40 kills across its two NCAA Tournament matches last year. Head coach Jamie Magalei has led the Orediggers to 14 NCAA Tournament berths before this season.
On the other side of the net, the Hilltoppers' postseason experience comes exclusively from St. Edward's most recent run, finishing runner-up in the LSC Championship match, marking the program's first conference tournament appearance since 2021.
What St. Edward's lacks in postseason experience, it makes up for in adaptability, showing the ability to adjust within matches and increasingly sustain its offense under pressure.
St. Edward's semifinal victory over Angelo State offered the clearest expression of that growth. Facing elimination after two sets, St. Edward's tightened its defense, then found another gear — hitting .317 in the fourth and .355 in the fifth to complete the reverse sweep upset.
The LSC Championship loss to DBU offers a timely look at the type of challenge awaiting it in the regional opener. Mines and DBU average nearly identical kills per set and hold opponents to almost matching hitting percentages, with the Orediggers bringing an even higher blocking rate.
Like DBU, Mines is larger up front, funneling everything through RMAC Offensive and Defensive Player of the Year, middle blocker Jenna McLaughlin in an attack directed by RMAC Setter of the Year, freshman Kaiya Gilbert.
The Orediggers have a slightly higher block percentage than the Patriots, but a little less punch from the service line. That last difference could mean everything for a match that could be won or lost on the first touch.
Since the start of conference play, St. Edward's back row has emerged as a secret weapon that head coach Jeremy Garcia touts as the deepest group he's coached. Libero GISELLE OJEDA anchors the unit, gaining more notoriety as the season moves along, earning All-LSC Honorable Mention and then LSC All-Tournament honors while surpassing 1,000 career digs.
BELLA BRICENO, BEA ANGELES, and even freshman IVY WACLAWCZYK have each earned regular rotation spots down the stretch, helping St. Edward's dictate the terms of most matches during conference play.
LSC Setter of the Year ALTHEA MORRIS thrives orchestrating a fast-paced offense, turning quality first passes into devastating kills.
In a matchup of the top two setters in the region, winning the serve-receive battle will allow the more experienced Morris to activate the Hilltoppers' deep cadre of attackers, led by All-LSC First Team outside hitter KELLI FORDING, through KAYLEN LEMBCKE, MIA CLAY, middles Jaime Carrington and GRACE MCDONALD, and the continued emergence of KARA WYNN.
Fording and Wynn demonstrated how dangerous those options can become against Angelo State, combining for 45 kills as the Hilltoppers worked their way back into the match. Fording followed with 14 kills against DBU, remaining productive even as the Patriots' block limited St. Edward's ability to sustain its attack.
Creating those opportunities more consistently will be essential against Mines. Clean passes give Morris access to the middle and force blockers to account for multiple attackers, opening space for the Hilltoppers to attack from the pins and taking advantage of St. Edward's athleticism and speed.
From the service line, St. Edward's must create the same uncertainty for Gilbert, making it harder for the freshman to establish McLaughlin and distribute the ball across the Orediggers' offense.
The Hilltoppers return to San Angelo having earned their place on the national stage. Their next opportunity begins with the first touch.